• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Family Law Specialists Edinburgh, Glasgow

  • Home
  • Our Services
    • Divorce & Separation
      • Collaborative Divorce
      • Divorce in Scotland
      • Expat Divorce & Separation
      • Finances
      • What should I expect?
    • Your Options
    • Children
      • Children and Divorce / Separation
      • Child Contact (Access)
      • Child Residence (Custody)
      • Modern Families
      • Parental Responsibilities and Rights
    • Modern Families
      • Fertility Fixed Fee Package
      • Assisted and Donor Conception
      • Surrogacy
      • Adoption
      • Parenthood for the Modern Family
      • Succession rights and estate planning for modern families
      • Family Friendly Employment Rights
    • Prenup & Cohab
    • Social Media Misuse
  • About Us
    • Why Us?
    • Our Experts
    • Testimonials
  • Our Costs
    • Fixed Fee Package
    • Fixed Fee Undefended Divorce
    • Fertility Fixed Fee Package
  • FAQ
  • Blog
    • Video Blogs
  • BTOyouStart
  • Contact Us

July 26, 2017 By Beverley Addison

The Perils of Pensions in Divorce – Part 2

If you are in the process of separating then The Supreme Court decision on McDonald v McDonald could have a huge impact on how your assets should be divided.


The perils of pensions in divorceIn August 2015 we reported on the appeal judgment in the case of McDonald v McDonald. Unsurprisingly Annie McDonald did indeed appeal and the Supreme Court has today ruled that the ‘period of membership’ to be used when apportioning pensions for the purposes of divorce should be the whole period of the membership rather than just the period of ‘active membership’. After a string of appeals through Scotland’s courts which previously held that it should only be the period of active (contributing) membership which should be taken into account, the decision provides some much needed clarity on the issue which has divided family lawyers for a number of years.

If you are in the process of separating then the decision could have a huge impact on how your assets should be divided…

Background

By way of a recap on the history of the case Thomas McDonald worked as a miner for British Coal. He joined their Pension Scheme on 11 December 1978. He married Annie McDonald on 22 March 1985. Five months later, on the 10 August 1985, he retired early on grounds of ill health and began to receive his pension.

The couple were married for 25 years and separated on 25 September 2010. As a result, Thomas’ pension scheme only received contributions for five months of their 25 year marriage. For the remaining years Thomas was a member of the scheme but a pensioner member as he was receiving his pension.

The dispute between them was what ‘period of membership’ counted for pension apportionment. Was it only the 5 months during which contributions were made to the scheme, or was it for the whole period of the marriage where Thomas continued to be a member, albeit only as a receiver of pensionable benefits.

The lower courts all found in favour of Thomas. However, today the Supreme Court decided that Annie McDonald’s interpretation of the legislation was to be preferred.

The Decision

This appeal raised questions of statutory interpretation both in relation to the 1985 Act and The Divorce etc. (Pensions) (Scotland) Regulations 2000 (“the 2000 Regulations”).

The apportionment of pensions has a prescribed formula for calculating how much of a pension value is attributed to the period of the marriage. It is contained within the 2000 Regulations as:

A x B/C where – A is the value of these rights or interests in any benefits under the pension arrangement which is calculated, as at the relevant date, in accordance with paragraph (2) of regulation 3 above…; and B is the period of C which falls within the period of the marriage of the parties before the relevant date and, if there is no such period, the amount shall be zero; and C is the period of the membership of that party in the pension arrangement before the relevant date…”

Thomas’ interpretation would have valued his interest in the pension benefits which fell to be matrimonial property as £10,002. Annie’s interpretation would value it at £138,534 – quite a difference!

There are four reasons why the Supreme Court decided that “membership” should not be confined to active membership of a pension scheme:-

  1. Interpreting the Regulations in this confined way involves adding words which are not there. The Supreme Court held that the drafters of the 2000 Regulations were clearly aware of the different categories of membership, as can be observed from the differentiation between categories of membership in Regulation 3, and chose not to differentiate in Regulation 4 between classes of membership. Accordingly, if they had intended ‘membership’ to refer only to active membership then it would have said so.
  2. The 2000 Regulations apply to both occupational pension schemes and personal pension schemes. The definition of “active membership” in section 124(1) of the Pensions Act 1995, on which Mr MacDonald sought to rely, was held to make no sense in relation to personal pension schemes. It must be assumed therefore that Parliament intended the 2000 Regulations to operate sensibly in respect of differing pension schemes.
  3. The reading of the word “active” or “contributing” into regulation 4 cannot be supported by referring to the focus in section 10(4) of the 1985 Act to the acquisition by the parties of assets during the marriage but before the relevant date. It was held that Section 10(5) of the 1985 Act deals specifically with pensions, and the opening words of section 10(4), which defines ‘matrimonial property’, states that the definition provided in section 10(4) is “subject to subsection (5) below” regarding Pensions. This means that Parliament specifically chose to deal with pensions differently by making a separate section in 10(5). It follows from the creation of that separate provision that the definition in section 10(4) could not be considered to apply to pensions and, therefore, the Inner House of the Court of Session erred in its reliance on it.
  4. Lastly, it was held that is not persuasive that “membership” in Regulation 4 must mean active membership in order to give meaning to the statement that factor B can be zero. They explained that if those drafting the wording of factors B and C in Regulation 4 intended to confine “membership” in such a way that would be a very indirect way to do it. They considered that there is no hint of such an intention in the words of the Regulations.

The court explained that their decision does not mean that the value of an interest in a pension must be shared equally. Section 9(1) of the 1985 Act of course contains other principles which inform the court’s decision and judges continue to have the powers of Section 9 open to them to adjust what percentage would justify a ‘fair sharing’ of the entire matrimonial pot. Special circumstances may persuade the court to award an unequal sharing of the matrimonial property on a case by case basis.

What does this mean for me?

If you are in the process of separating then the decision could have a huge impact on how your assets should be divided, particularly if they include a pension which has been valued based on ‘active membership’ only. The difference in the valuations of the pension in the McDonald’s case was almost £120,000. The Supreme Court has finally given family solicitors clarity on how pensions should be apportioned. Their decision will no doubt be welcomed by many whose separated spouse is the pension member, as there will also be numerous spouses who will rue the day that Annie McDonald took her fight to the Supreme Court. If you have any concerns about how this decision may impact your financial settlement you should contact a family law solicitor as soon as possible.

More to Read

The Perils of Pensions in Divorce Divorce Myths Busted!Some Urban Divorce Myths – Busted! You Keep Yours and I’ll Keep Mine The New Pension Reforms – Benefits and Risks for Separating CouplesThe New Pension Reforms – Benefits and Risks for Separating Couples

Filed Under: Finances, Separation and Divorce Tagged With: divorce and pensions, pension sharing, pensions

Beverley Addison

Beverley Addison

Beverley is a Senior Solicitor within our Family Law team who specialises in fertility law, including the law of surrogacy, IVF and becoming parents in a modern family. She is experienced in dealing with all aspects of family law including financial provision on separation and divorce, cohabitation and cases relating to children. Read Beverley's professional biography.

What our clients say

Help guiding us through a very stressful time

I would like to thank you again for all your work and help guiding us through a very stressful time.

Read more testimonials

From our first meeting, I felt confident…

Hi Debbie, I wanted to take this opportunity to pass on my gratitude to you for getting me through this. From our first meeting, I felt confident and assured to be in your safe hands and that never changed during the last 18 months. Whilst it is a great relief to have this finished I… Read more “From our first meeting, I felt confident…”

Read more testimonials

Things have been finalised in about twelve weeks

Amanda, many thanks for seeing all this through for me. I cannot believe that after the best part of two and a half years of frustration (pre BTO), things have been finalised in about twelve weeks.

Read more testimonials

I am eternally grateful

I am in no doubt I have made the correct choice by having BTO Solicitors represent me in such a difficult time. I am under no illusion you and your team will continue to do the best for me in future. Many many thanks for today. I am eternally grateful.

Read more testimonials

Our anxieties were greatly alleviated

Lesley, thank you so much for all your help. It turned out to be a very uncomplicated matter in the end and probably not the most interesting for you. However our anxieties were greatly alleviated with your advice and work

Read more testimonials

Efficient and smooth service

Debbie, could I take this opportunity to thank you for the efficient and smooth service you have provided, and particularly, in our first meeting when you listened to my concerns and really helped explain things and put my mind at ease.

Read more testimonials

Guiding me through a difficult time

Lesley, I would like to take this opportunity to thank you for your professionalism. Guiding me through a difficult time, also your understanding and empathy as to my personal situation. I would not hesitate in recommending your services to others.

Read more testimonials

Great service

Beverley thank you so much for all your hard work and making things run as smoothly as possible. Great service.

Read more testimonials

I was very pleased with how things went today

Hi Beverley – I would just like to email you to thank you for your services today and commend you on doing a stellar job. I was very pleased with how things went today. The level of professionalism you showed was much to my satisfaction and greatly appreciated. I felt very relaxed at having you… Read more “I was very pleased with how things went today”

Read more testimonials

I came out of your offices feeling great!

Marjory, thank you for a really positive meeting on Friday. I feel things are a lot clearer in my head – I came out of your offices feeling great!

Read more testimonials

Wonderful job

I would like to thank you Lesley again for the wonderful job you and your team did for me at a very difficult time in my life.

Read more testimonials

Their service and support has been excellent

After quite a complex case, I can say that their service and support has been excellent.

Read more testimonials

You have smoothed the pathway with your efficiency

Amanda…May I take this opportunity to thank you for your help in these matters. Although I am a resilient person, it has not been easy, but you have smoothed the pathway with your efficiency…

Read more testimonials

An Excellent Lawyer…

Beverley thanks for all your assistance with everything. It’s much appreciated and rest assured should I ever need an excellent lawyer in the future you will be the first to be called.

Read more testimonials

I would like to thank my exceptional Scottish team

My dear legal team! I have been writing this letter of thanks in my head since about two months ago, and didn’t know it would take a bit longer than expected to actually be able to express my deep gratitude to you ALL for winning this tough and enduring process for me……I would like to… Read more “I would like to thank my exceptional Scottish team”

Read more testimonials

Outstanding job…

Marjory… you are doing an outstanding job… Thanks again for your support and expertise in helping me navigate through this horrible situation. I really appreciate it.

Read more testimonials

After all these years I’m finally free

Thank you so so much Amanda. Actually there’s no words to thank you. I feel great. After all these years I’m finally free. Thank you.

Read more testimonials

Very approachable manner

Many thanks Marjory for your very approachable manner during our meetings.

Read more testimonials

I will definitely recommend you…

Hi Marjory, thanks again for being an absolute joy to work with during this unknown and nerve-wracking process. You made me feel calm and reassured throughout (not an easy task). I will definitely recommend you to anyone else looking for representation.

Read more testimonials

Your advice has been incredibly helpful

Beverley thank you for everything you’ve done regarding my case and for your assistance in getting the many issues resolved and matters concluded. Your advice has been incredibly helpful and greatly appreciated. Should I require any further assistance, I will be in touch.

Read more testimonials

My recent collaborative process

Dear Marjory, I just wanted to say a huge thanks for all your help, advice and counsel throughout my recent collaborative process. You definitely made a difficult process easier for me. Thank you.

Read more testimonials

Help during this extremely difficult time

Debbie, I would just like to thank you for your help during this extremely difficult time. I really appreciate it.

Read more testimonials

I would recommend you to anyone

Hi Marjory and Keira, I just want to thank you both for taking me through this terrible time in my life. I have learned a lot in the past 3 years with dealing with BTO and I would recommend you to anyone as you have been very fair and honest with all parties concerned.

Read more testimonials

Excellent communications and support

Many thanks for your recent work related to my divorce…..I would particularly like to thank Amanda Richardson for her excellent communications and support.

Read more testimonials

We would not have managed this without you

Marjory, I think we can all honestly say that we would not have managed this without you, truly you have been an absolute star and we are all very thankful.

Read more testimonials

Splendid work Marjory

Splendid work Marjory, it has been a treat to use BTO and your services.

Read more testimonials

Always appreciated being able to rely fully on you and the team

Amanda and Lesley, thank you to you both for all your help, now and during last year, and, as I said before, I have always appreciated being able to rely fully on you and the team at all times. Obviously, a very sad time for me but I am relieved that it is at an… Read more “Always appreciated being able to rely fully on you and the team”

Read more testimonials

Highly professional and excellent services

Debbie, I would like to express my sincere gratitude for the highly professional and excellent services I received from yourself and your team.

Read more testimonials

Highly professional and meticulous in detail

Highly professional and meticulous in detail. No shortcuts or compromises involved, ensuring all eventualities were covered and underwritten with third-party expertise where appropriate.

Read more testimonials

Forever I will be grateful…

Marjory, forever I will be grateful and thankful to you for all the hard work you did for me and my family. Thank you very much again and again. I am so very blessed in life that I found a lovely understanding person like you. Not many lawyers would say go and have a cup… Read more “Forever I will be grateful…”

Read more testimonials

All starting to come together…

Thanks Marjory, it’s all starting to come together.. thanks to you…:)

Read more testimonials

I still get to see my kids 3 times a week

Just wanted to say a huge thank you for your help and representation today. It’s such a relief to hear that I still get to see my kids 3 times a week. Also last but by no means least can you pass on my profound gratitude to Counsel who was a star !!!!

Read more testimonials

Approachable and sensitive manner

Marjory, thank you very much for your very approachable and sensitive manner during our meetings.

Read more testimonials

Financial knowledge and gravitas

Lesley has financial knowledge and gravitas. I think she is faultless.

Read more testimonials

I certainly feel like a weight has been lifted off my shoulders

Marjory, I just wanted to say thanks very much for your help right throughout the case. Lately, the ad hoc support has been invaluable and given me the confidence to keep representing myself and not feel pushed into agreeing something I’m not comfortable with. I appreciate how difficult it must be to provide support when… Read more “I certainly feel like a weight has been lifted off my shoulders”

Read more testimonials

Thank you for your professionalism and talent

Thanks Debbie, as always, for your professionalism and talent, it has been a pleasure.

Read more testimonials

I won’t hesitate to put them in touch with you

Looking back I wish my ex-wife and I would have gone down the collaborative divorce path but as you know she chose a very different way which ended up being most certainly a longer, more stressful and more expensive path for both of us. Should I ever hear of anyone whose marriage has reached that… Read more “I won’t hesitate to put them in touch with you”

Read more testimonials

I have come out of the process a much stronger person

I would have no hesitation recommending Lesley Gordon to anyone I know who needs the services of a divorce lawyer. It was a very positive experience all things considered and I have come out of the process a much stronger person thanks to Lesley.

Read more testimonials

I left the offices empowered and liberated

Just wanted to say huge thank you to Lesley Gordon. I left the offices empowered and liberated. Not sure any psychologist would have done a better job! On top of her real job.

Read more testimonials

Thanks for all the expert guidance through a trying situation

Hi Marjory, my daughter and her son are doing great. Everything seems to have calmed down. She and her husband finished the mediation process after a couple of visits as they both felt they had to step up to the mark for their son’s sake not for personal reasons. Once again thanks for all the… Read more “Thanks for all the expert guidance through a trying situation”

Read more testimonials

Risk assessed everything

They explained everything to me very clearly and we looked at every permutation and possible outcome and risk assessed everything.

Read more testimonials

Footer

Contact Us

Edinburgh
0131 222 2959
Glasgow
0141 225 4848
Email
familylaw@bto.co.uk

About Us

We are award winning family and divorce lawyers based in Edinburgh and Glasgow and covering the whole of Scotland, including cross border issues, specialising in divorce and all aspects of child and family law. Learn More

  • Email
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

BTO Chambers top ranked logoBTO Legal 500 ranked logo

Copyright © 2021 BTO Solicitors LLP · All Rights Reserved · Privacy Notice · Terms & Conditions · Anti-Money Laundering Policy

This site uses cookies: Find out more.